Breaking Down a Sale Comp in Commercial Real Estate: Key Metrics and Their Importance

SKIP AHEAD TO

• Key Data Points in a Sale Comp
• How to Find Sale Comps with CompStak

In the commercial real estate (CRE) industry, sale comps (comparable sales) are invaluable tools for investors, brokers, and analysts. They provide a comprehensive snapshot of sales activity, offering insights into market trends and helping stakeholders make informed decisions. Understanding sale comps is essential for anyone aiming to refine their investment strategies with accurate market data.

Key Data Points in a Sale Comp

Property Address and Location

• Definition: The specific address and geographical location of the commercial property that was sold.
• Importance: Location remains one of the most critical factors in determining property value. Properties in prime or emerging locations typically command higher prices, benefiting from strong demand and appreciation potential. For example, commercial real estate sales in areas like central business districts often showcase higher per-square-foot pricing due to proximity to major business hubs, transportation, and amenities. In contrast, properties in suburban or secondary markets may offer lower entry prices but could present higher long-term growth opportunities depending on local market trends.

Sale Price

• Definition: The total price at which the property was sold.
• Importance: Sale price is the fundamental metric in a sale comp, reflecting the value the market places on a specific property. Analyzing sale prices across similar properties helps investors gauge market trends and set realistic expectations for future deals. For example, knowing the recent sale price of a comparable office building or retail space helps investors and appraisers determine fair market value, adjust for inflation, and make pricing decisions in negotiations.

Price Per Square Foot

• Definition: The sale price divided by the total square footage of the property.
• Importance: Price per square foot standardizes the comparison across properties of different sizes. This metric is crucial for determining the relative value of a property and is often a primary factor in comparing similar assets. 

According to CompStak data, in 2024 year to date, the average sales price per square foot for industrial properties of 100,000 square feet or larger in the Los Angeles-Orange-Inland Empire market has been $283,86 per square foot, which outpaces the average in Phoenix, overall, of $204.54 per square foot by 38.8%.

Cap Rate (Capitalization Rate)

• Definition: A rate used to estimate the return on investment, calculated by dividing the property’s net operating income (NOI) by its sale price.
• Importance: The cap rate is a key indicator of the property’s expected return, factoring in both risk and future income potential. A lower cap rate often indicates a lower-risk investment in a highly sought-after market, whereas a higher cap rate suggests greater risk but potentially higher returns. Investors use cap rate comparisons to determine if they are achieving a reasonable return on their investment relative to market conditions and risk levels.

Building Size and Square Footage

• Definition: The total size of the building, typically measured in square feet.
• Importance: The size of the building directly impacts its functionality and marketability. Larger properties may offer economies of scale, while smaller properties might appeal to niche buyers or investors seeking to diversify their portfolios. Additionally, understanding how the building’s size relates to sale price helps determine the value per square foot, which is essential for comparing properties of different sizes.

Date of Sale

• Definition: The specific date when the property transaction was finalized.
• Importance: The date of sale is crucial for understanding market trends over time. Sale prices fluctuate with changes in the economy, interest rates, and market demand. For example, a property sold during an economic downturn may fetch a lower price compared to a similar sale during a boom period. Analyzing sale dates within specific timeframes allows investors to track price movements and time their market entry or exit strategically.

Building Class (A, B, C)

• Definition: A classification that ranks properties based on their quality, age, location, and amenities (Class A, B, or C).
• Importance: The building class provides insight into the property’s overall desirability and expected performance in the market. Class A buildings, typically newer with high-end finishes and located in prime areas, command the highest prices. Class B and C buildings, while more affordable, may offer value-add opportunities for investors willing to invest in upgrades. Understanding building class helps investors and brokers set realistic price expectations and assess the level of risk associated with a property.

Zoning

• Definition: The legal designation that determines how a property can be used (ie commercial, residential, mixed-use).
• Importance: Zoning laws play a critical role in determining a property’s potential. Properties in areas with flexible zoning or future zoning changes can see significant appreciation as they become eligible for redevelopment or higher-value uses. Sale comps often reflect premiums for properties with favorable zoning, as these offer broader development opportunities and increased investment potential.

Condition of the Property

• Definition: The state of the property at the time of sale, including any necessary repairs or upgrades.
• Importance: The condition of a property affects both its sale price and its potential for future appreciation. Well-maintained properties typically command higher prices, while those in need of renovation may sell for less but offer value-add opportunities. Investors often seek sale comps that reflect properties in similar condition to accurately assess the cost-benefit of purchasing an asset that requires additional capital investment.

Tenant Occupancy

• Definition: The occupancy rate of the property at the time of sale, including any existing leases.
• Importance: A property with high tenant occupancy offers immediate cash flow, which can be an attractive selling point for investors. Conversely, properties with low or no occupancy may require repositioning or lease-up strategies but might be acquired at a discount. Understanding tenant occupancy helps investors assess a property’s risk and income potential.

How to Find Sale Comps with CompStak

CompStak offers a comprehensive platform for accessing detailed sale comps, providing the data needed to make informed investment decisions. Leverage CompStak for your CRE needs:

• Accurate Data: CompStak aggregates sale comp data from a vast network of industry professionals, ensuring accuracy and reliability.
• User-Friendly Platform: The platform’s intuitive interface makes it easy to find, analyze, and compare sale comps across various property types and markets.
• Customizable Reports: Generate tailored reports that meet your specific investment or valuation needs, making it easier to share insights with stakeholders.